Pickly

Beauty

Best Eyeliners 2026: Maybelline vs NYX vs Urban Decay

WriterPickly Editorial

Updated 2026-11-17

Spec-verifiedLast reviewed 2026-11-17AI-drafted desk research based on public specs, manufacturer data and independent reviews — not hands-on tested

Eyeliner comes as liquid pens, gel pencils and creamy pencils, and almost every listing promises waterproof, smudge-proof wear for up to 24 hours. The real differences are the tip you can draw with, how easily it blends and how much it costs. This guide compares five popular eyeliners on type, stated wear time and price, using the Amazon listings.

Quick answer

For most people the Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen is the best starter liquid liner: a flex-tip brush, a waterproof formula and a stated 24-hour wear for about $9. NYX Epic Ink is the matte liquid option, wet n wild Mega Last is the budget liquid, Maybelline Tattoo Studio is the blendable gel pencil for smoky looks, and Urban Decay 24/7 is the premium creamy pencil.

📋How we compared

We compared each eyeliner on type (liquid pen or pencil), stated wear time and waterproofing, tip and applicator, finish, claims such as vegan or cruelty-free, and price, using the Amazon listings. We have not applied or worn these products, so we do not rate real-world smudging, comfort or removal; wear times are the makers' claims.

★ Best Pick

Best Starter Liquid Liner: A liquid pen with a flex-tip brush and a hexagonal grip, described as skip-free, waterproof and smudge-resistant, with a satin finish and wear of up to 24 hours (maker's claim). At about $9 it is an easy first liquid liner, because the brush tip flexes and gives control.

Top picks ↓
  1. 1Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner
    Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner
    ABest Starter Liquid Liner
    $8.98Price as of 2026-11-18
  2. 2NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
    NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
    A-Best Matte Liquid Liner
    $9.99Price as of 2026-11-18
  3. 3wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner
    wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner
    B+Best Budget Liquid Liner
    $5.47Price as of 2026-11-18
  4. 4Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil
    Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil
    A-Best Smoky Gel Pencil
    $8.98Price as of 2026-11-18
  5. 5Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
    A-Best Premium Pencil
    $25Price as of 2026-11-18

Which one is right for you?

1★ Best PickABest Starter Liquid LinerMaybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner

A liquid pen with a flex-tip brush and a hexagonal grip, described as skip-free, waterproof and smudge-resistant, with a satin finish and wear of up to 24 hours (maker's claim).

A liquid pen with a flex-tip brush and a hexagonal grip, described as skip-free, waterproof and smudge-resistant, with a satin finish and wear of up to 24 hours (maker's claim). At about $9 it is an easy first liquid liner, because the brush tip flexes and gives control. On Amazon US it was $8.98 on November 17, 2026.

Pros

  • ✓Flex-tip brush with grip
  • ✓Waterproof formula
  • ✓About $9

Cons

  • ✗Satin finish, not matte
  • ✗24-hour wear is a claim
Specifications
Type
Liquid pen
Finish
Satin
Wear (claimed)
Up to 24 hours
Waterproof
Yes (per listing)

2A-Best Matte Liquid LinerNYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

A waterproof matte black liquid eyeliner with an ultra-precise, flexible tip: pressing slightly thicker makes a bolder line.

A waterproof matte black liquid eyeliner with an ultra-precise, flexible tip: pressing slightly thicker makes a bolder line. The listing says up to 24 hours of wear and a smudge-proof, transfer-resistant formula, and that it is vegan and cruelty-free. It suits a sharp cat-eye in a matte finish. On Amazon US it was $9.99 on November 17, 2026.

Pros

  • ✓Matte black finish
  • ✓Precise flexible tip
  • ✓Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons

  • ✗Slightly higher price than wet n wild
  • ✗24-hour wear is a claim
Specifications
Type
Liquid pen
Finish
Matte
Wear (claimed)
Up to 24 hours
Vegan
Yes (per listing)

3B+Best Budget Liquid Linerwet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner

wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner

A waterproof liquid liner with an ultra-fine brush tip that, per the listing, makes lines from thin to bold and has a tank delivery system for steady ink flow.

A waterproof liquid liner with an ultra-fine brush tip that, per the listing, makes lines from thin to bold and has a tank delivery system for steady ink flow. The listing claims 16 hours of wear and describes it as smudge-, flake- and cry-proof, vegan and cruelty-free. At about $5 it is the cheapest liquid option here. On Amazon US it was $5.47 on November 17, 2026.

Pros

  • ✓About $5
  • ✓Ultra-fine brush tip
  • ✓Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons

  • ✗16-hour claim, shorter than rivals'
  • ✗Less brand prestige
Specifications
Type
Liquid
Brush
Ultra-fine
Wear (claimed)
16 hours
Vegan
Yes (per listing)

Subscribe to our newsletter

Occasional updates and new releases — no spam.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

4A-Best Smoky Gel PencilMaybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil

A dual-ended mechanical gel pencil with a precision blender for smoky looks, with a smudge-resistant waterproof matte finish.

A dual-ended mechanical gel pencil with a precision blender for smoky looks, with a smudge-resistant waterproof matte finish. The listing says up to 36 hours of wear (a maker's claim), four colours and that it is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for contact lens wearers. It is the easy choice for tightlining or smudged-out liner. On Amazon US it was $8.98 on November 17, 2026.

Pros

  • ✓Blendable, built-in blender
  • ✓No sharpening needed
  • ✓Ophthalmologist tested, contact-lens suitable (per listing)

Cons

  • ✗36-hour claim is optimistic
  • ✗Less precise than a liquid for wings
Specifications
Type
Mechanical gel pencil
Finish
Matte
Wear (claimed)
Up to 36 hours
Colours
4

5A-Best Premium PencilUrban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

A creamy, sharpenable pencil in more than 30 shades with a skip-free formula, infused with 50% hydrating ingredients such as vitamin E and jojoba oil, and waterproof wear of up to 16 hours (maker's claim).

A creamy, sharpenable pencil in more than 30 shades with a skip-free formula, infused with 50% hydrating ingredients such as vitamin E and jojoba oil, and waterproof wear of up to 16 hours (maker's claim). It is vegan and cruelty-free, and works for wings, tightlining or smudged smoky eyes. At about $23 it costs far more than drugstore pencils. On Amazon US it was $23.00 on November 17, 2026.

Pros

  • ✓30+ shades
  • ✓Creamy, no-tug formula
  • ✓Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons

  • ✗About $23
  • ✗Needs sharpening
Specifications
Type
Creamy pencil
Shades
30+
Wear (claimed)
Up to 16 hours
Sharpenable
Yes

Side-by-side on the same scale

ProductTypeFinishWaterproofVeganBrushColoursShadesSharpenable
Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen EyelinerLiquid penSatinUp to 24 hoursYes (per listing)—————
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink LinerLiquid penMatteUp to 24 hours—Yes (per listing)————
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid EyelinerLiquid—16 hours—Yes (per listing)Ultra-fine———
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel PencilMechanical gel pencilMatteUp to 36 hours———4——
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye PencilCreamy pencil—Up to 16 hours————30+Yes

How to read this table: values come from the Amazon product listings for the linked products, checked in November 2026. Wear-time hours are the makers' own claims. Shades and prices vary by listing. “—” means the value could not be confirmed.

Table checked 2026-11-17

Top pick: Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen

The Maybelline Hyper Easy pen is our starter pick: a flex-tip brush, a hexagonal grip, a waterproof formula and a satin finish for about $9. It is the easiest liquid liner here to control.

The 24-hour wear claim is Maybelline's own; real-world wear depends on your skin and the weather.

The liquid picks: NYX Epic Ink and wet n wild Mega Last

NYX Epic Ink is the matte liquid option with a flexible precise tip for sharp wings, and it is vegan and cruelty-free. wet n wild Mega Last is the budget liquid at about $5, with an ultra-fine brush and a 16-hour wear claim.

Both are waterproof, according to the listings.

The pencil picks: Maybelline Tattoo Studio and Urban Decay 24/7

Maybelline Tattoo Studio is a mechanical gel pencil with a built-in blender for smoky looks and tightlining. Urban Decay 24/7 is a creamy, sharpenable pencil in 30+ shades with 50% hydrating ingredients for about $23.

Pencils are easier to smudge and blend than liquid liners, but less sharp for wings.

How to choose an eyeliner

Pick the type by the look: liquid for sharp wings, gel or creamy pencil for smoky or tightlined eyes. Then check the finish (matte or satin), shade range and whether it is waterproof if you wear contact lenses or sweat.

Treat wear-time claims as marketing and remember that waterproof liners need an oil-based or dedicated remover. If you have sensitive eyes or an eye condition, ask an eye doctor before trying new products.

Frequently asked questions

Which is easier for beginners, liquid or pencil eyeliner?▼
A pencil is usually easier for beginners because you can draw and smudge it freely, and a gel or creamy pencil is forgiving. A liquid pen with a flexible tip, such as the Maybelline Hyper Easy, is the easiest liquid option.
Are waterproof eyeliners safe for contact lens wearers?▼
Some listings, such as the Maybelline Tattoo Studio, say the product is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for contact lens wearers. Check each product's listing and packaging, and ask an eye doctor if you have concerns.
How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?▼
Waterproof formulas usually need an oil-based remover or a dedicated eye makeup remover; rubbing hard with water can irritate the eyes. Follow the product's directions.
Do 24-hour or 36-hour claims mean it will last that long?▼
No. They are the makers' claims from lab or consumer tests. Oily lids, humidity and rubbing shorten wear, so use the hours only as a rough comparison.

Check the details of the products in this article

Prices change. Check the retailer for the current price.

Ad — This article contains affiliate links.Affiliate disclosure

Comments & questions

Discussion happens on nattzy, our community forum. Sign in with Google to post — it takes a second.

Still deciding? Ask the community your own question — Post a question on nattzy ↗

Related articles

Recently viewed

You have not viewed any items yet.

Prices and stock change all the time. Please check the latest details at the store before you buy.