Best Medicare Supplement Insurance 2026: 5 Plan G Carriers
WriterPickly Editorial
Updated 2026-09-10
Five Medicare Supplement carriers. Same 65-year-old non-smoker. Published Plan G rates in Florida, Texas and California — the three states where premium differences are widest.
Quick answer
For most 65-year-old buyers, Mutual of Omaha is the pick — a mutual company where policyholders share dividends, an A+ AM Best rating and stable Plan G pricing, which is what matters when rates compound over decades. Aetna bundles SilverSneakers plus hearing and vision discounts, Blue Cross Blue Shield offers the largest state networks, UnitedHealthcare AARP is the largest single insurer, and Humana runs $145-200 a month mid-tier.
📋How we compared
This comparison is desk research. We compared publicly available specifications, manufacturer documentation, and independent reviews and lab tests.
🏆 Best mutual carrier: Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement is the right pick for stability-focused buyers. Mutual company (policyholders share dividends), A+ AM Best rating, Plan G $150-200/mo.
Top picks ↓Which one is right for you?
Related articles
1★ Best Pick🏆 Best mutual carrierMutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement
Quote through Mutual of Omaha advisors. Long history of dividend-paying.
Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement is the right pick for stability-focused buyers. Mutual company (policyholders share dividends), A+ AM Best rating, Plan G $150-200/mo. Rate-increase history is moderate. Strong long-term carrier.
Pros
- ✓Mutual company (dividends)
- ✓A+ AM Best rating
- ✓Solid long-term stability
Cons
- ✗Not always cheapest in your state
- ✗Customer service is mid-tier
2💚 Best bundled extrasAetna Medicare Supplement (CVS Health)
Quote at aetnamedicare.com — CVS Health-owned.
Aetna Medicare Supplement (CVS Health) is the right pick if you value bundled extras. SilverSneakers gym membership included, hearing aid discounts, vision discounts. Cheapest ($140-190/mo across states). Owned by CVS Health.
Pros
- ✓SilverSneakers included
- ✓Cheapest
- ✓CVS Health backing
Cons
- ✗Rate-increase history average
- ✗A AM Best (not A+)
3🪪 Best mid-tier optionHumana Medicare Supplement
Quote at humana.com — solid mid-tier option.
Humana Medicare Supplement is a solid mid-tier option. Plan G $145-200/mo, strong Medicare Advantage cross-sell if you ever want to switch. Available in most states. Less aggressive on bundled extras but reliable.
Pros
- ✓Reliable mid-tier carrier
- ✓Cross-sell to MA if needed
- ✓Wide state availability
Cons
- ✗Less bundled extras than Aetna
- ✗Mid-tier rate-increase history
Subscribe to our newsletter
Occasional updates and new releases — no spam.
4🌐 Best network coverageBlue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Supplement
Quote at bcbs.com — pricing varies dramatically by state BCBS.
Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Supplement is the right pick if you want the largest network in your state. State-specific BCBS plans vary in pricing — some states have very competitive BCBS pricing, others are highest in this comparison. Check your state.
Pros
- ✓Largest provider network in most states
- ✓Strong state-level brand recognition
- ✓Trusted by hospitals
Cons
- ✗Highly state-variable pricing
- ✗AM Best rating varies by state BCBS
5👑 Best brand recognitionUnitedHealthcare AARP Medicare Supplement
Quote at aarpmedicaresupplement.com — AARP endorsement required (AARP membership $16/year).
UnitedHealthcare AARP Medicare Supplement is the largest single Medicare Supplement insurer in the US. AARP-endorsed, A+ AM Best rating, includes Renew Active (gym + brain games). Plan G $150-210/mo. Strong stability and brand recognition.
Pros
- ✓Largest US Medicare Supplement insurer
- ✓AARP endorsement
- ✓Renew Active gym/brain games
Cons
- ✗Not always cheapest
- ✗Brand premium may not be worth the extra cost
What Plan G covers
Plan G covers everything Original Medicare doesn't, EXCEPT the Part B deductible ($240/year in 2026). Plan F (which covered Part B deductible) was discontinued for new enrollees in 2020.
Plan G is the most popular for new enrollees post-2020 because it covers the same expensive gaps (Part A deductible, Part B coinsurance, etc.) at lower premium than Plan F historical cost.
Plan G alternatives: Plan N (lower premium, $20 copay per office visit + $50 ER copay) for healthy seniors who don't visit doctors often. Plan G is the safe default.
Premium by carrier and state
65-year-old Plan G monthly premium by state and carrier: Florida averages $180-220 (highest), Texas $130-170, California $150-200. Florida's high premiums are due to retirement demographics and hurricane risk.
Cheapest carrier: Aetna $140-190/mo across states. Most expensive: Blue Cross Blue Shield $160-220/mo (varies by state BCBS).
Rate-increase history (5 years): UnitedHealthcare AARP averaged 4-6% annual increases, Mutual of Omaha 5-7%, Aetna 5-8%, Humana 4-7%, BCBS varies widely by state. Rate stability matters more than initial premium for long-term holders.
Bundled benefits and customer service
Bundled extras: Aetna includes SilverSneakers gym membership (worth $25-50/mo equivalent), free hearing aid discounts, vision discounts. UnitedHealthcare AARP includes Renew Active (gym + brain games). Mutual of Omaha includes basic discount programs. Humana and BCBS more limited extras.
Customer service ratings (BBB + AM Best): UnitedHealthcare A+ AM Best, Mutual of Omaha A+ AM Best, Aetna A AM Best, Humana A AM Best, BCBS varies by state.
Pre-existing condition treatment: Medicare Supplement is guaranteed issue ONLY during Open Enrollment (first 6 months after Part B starts). Outside that window, carriers can underwrite — and decline.
Frequently asked questions
Plan G vs Plan N?▼
When should I enroll?▼
Can I switch carriers later?▼
Medicare Supplement vs Medicare Advantage?▼
Check the details of the products in this article
- Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement$130〜$300Reference price
- Aetna Medicare Supplement (CVS Health)$130〜$280Reference price
- Humana Medicare Supplement$130〜$300Reference price
- Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Supplement$140〜$320Reference price
- UnitedHealthcare AARP Medicare Supplement$135〜$290Reference price
Prices change. Check the retailer for the current price.
Comments & questions
Discussion happens on nattzy, our community forum. Sign in with Google to post — it takes a second.
View the discussion thread on nattzy ↗
Still deciding? Ask the community your own question — Post a question on nattzy ↗
