Best Capture Card 2026: 5 Picks from $129.99 to $249.99

WriterPickly Editorial

Updated 2026-10-05

SourcedLast reviewed 2026-10-05

A capture card takes the HDMI signal from a console or a second PC and sends it to a computer for streaming or recording. It has two jobs with two separate limits: what it passes through to your TV or monitor, and what it records.

Quick answer

The Elgato 4K S at $159.99 is the capture card to buy for most streamers: 4K60 capture with passthrough up to 4K60 or 1440p120. The Elgato Game Capture Neo at $129.99 is the lower-priced pick, capturing 1080p60 while passing 4K60 HDR to the TV. The Elgato 4K X at $249.99 captures and passes through up to 4K144 for high refresh rate play. AVerMedia's Live Gamer Ultra 2.1, on sale at $199.99, is the HDMI 2.1 alternative with headset jacks for party chat, and the Elgato HD60 X at $179.99 is the older model with VRR passthrough.

Check price: Elgato Game Capture Neo →

📋

We did not run our own testing on these capture cards. Measuring latency and checking compatibility needs each card connected to several consoles and computers, and we have not done that. What we did instead: took capture resolution, passthrough resolution and connection type from each manufacturer's product pages and comparison articles, checked prices on the makers' own US stores on October 4, 2026, and read owner reviews in volume. We kept only specific complaints that repeat, such as audio drifting out of sync, the card not being detected and HDR footage looking washed out.

★ Best Pick

Elgato Game Capture 4K S

$159.99Reference price

View deal →

🏆 Best overall: The 4K S captures up to 4K60 and passes through up to 4K60 or 1440p120, for $159.99 on Elgato's store. That covers 4K recording and 1080p streaming from a current console at a price below the older HD60 X.

View deal →

Top picks ↓

Best microSD Cards 2026: Samsung vs SanDisk vs Lexar 1066x

Tech · 5

Best Rewards Credit Cards 2026: 5 Compared for Points

Finance · 5

Best Secured Credit Card 2026: 5 That Build Credit

Finance · 5

1★ Best Pick🏆 Best overallElgato Game Capture 4K S

External USB card. 4K60 capture, passthrough up to 4K60 or 1440p120.

The 4K S captures up to 4K60 and passes through up to 4K60 or 1440p120, for $159.99 on Elgato's store. That covers 4K recording and 1080p streaming from a current console at a price below the older HD60 X. Its passthrough stops at 60Hz in 4K, so players on a 4K 120Hz screen will give up the higher refresh rate while the card is connected.

Pros

✓4K60 capture
✓1440p120 passthrough
✓$159.99

Cons

✗No 4K120 passthrough
✗Needs a fast USB port

Elgato Game Capture 4K S

$159.99Reference price

Product details →

Amazon →

2⭐ Best valueElgato Game Capture Neo

External USB card. 1080p60 capture, 4K60 HDR passthrough.

The Game Capture Neo captures at 1080p60 and passes 4K60 HDR through to the TV, for $129.99. That matches what most streams are sent at, and you still play in 4K. It cannot record in 4K, and it sits only $30 below the 4K S, so it suits people who are sure they will stream and not make 4K videos.

Pros

✓$129.99
✓4K60 HDR passthrough
✓1080p60 suits streaming

Cons

✗No 4K capture
✗Only $30 below the 4K S

Elgato Game Capture Neo

$129.99Reference price

Product details →

Amazon →

3⚡ Best for high refresh ratesElgato Game Capture 4K X

External USB card. Capture and passthrough up to 4K144.

The 4K X lists capture up to 4K144 and passthrough up to 4K144 or 1440p240, the highest figures in Elgato's external range. It costs $249.99. It lets a PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X or gaming PC keep 120Hz while capturing. Recording at those rates produces very large files and needs a strong computer.

Pros

✓4K144 capture
✓4K144 / 1440p240 passthrough
✓Keeps 120Hz console play

Cons

✗$249.99
✗Demanding on the computer

Elgato Game Capture 4K X

$249.99Reference price

Product details →

Amazon →

Subscribe to our newsletter

Occasional updates and new releases — no spam.

4🎧 Best for party chatAVerMedia Live Gamer Ultra 2.1 (GC553G2)

Model GC553G2. $199.99 was a sale price; regular price $299.99.

The Live Gamer Ultra 2.1 has HDMI 2.1 in and out, with passthrough listed up to 4K144 or 1440p240 with HDR and VRR. AVerMedia lists capture up to 4K144 on Windows and 4K60 on macOS over USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C. Its 3.5mm jacks bring headset and controller audio into the capture for party chat. It was $199.99 on sale against a $299.99 regular price.

Pros

✓HDMI 2.1 with VRR passthrough
✓Headset and controller audio jacks
✓$199.99 on sale

Cons

✗$299.99 regular price
✗4K60 capture limit on macOS

AVerMedia Live Gamer Ultra 2.1 (GC553G2)

$199.99Reference price

Product details →

Amazon →

5🔄 Best older model with VRRElgato Game Capture HD60 X

External USB card. 1080p60 HDR10 or 4K30 capture, 4K60 passthrough with VRR.

The HD60 X captures 1080p60 HDR10 or 4K30 and passes through up to 4K60 HDR10 with VRR. It costs $179.99, which is $20 more than the newer 4K S with 4K60 capture. Its case is VRR passthrough and a long record of use with streaming software. For most buyers the 4K S is now the better purchase.

Pros

✓VRR passthrough
✓1080p60 HDR10 capture
✓Long track record

Cons

✗4K capture limited to 30fps
✗Costs more than the 4K S

Elgato Game Capture HD60 X

$179.99Reference price

Product details →

Amazon →

Capture and passthrough are two different numbers

Passthrough is the signal the card hands on to your TV or monitor. It decides how the game looks and feels to you while you play. Capture is the signal sent to the computer. It decides what your viewers see or what gets recorded.

The two can differ. The Game Capture Neo passes 4K60 HDR to the TV and captures at 1080p60. You play in 4K and stream in 1080p, which is the resolution most streams are sent at anyway.

The table shows each maker's figures and the price on its own US store on October 4, 2026.

Capture card	Max capture	Max passthrough	Price seen
Elgato Game Capture Neo	1080p60	4K60 HDR	$129.99
Elgato 4K S	4K60	4K60 / 1440p120	$159.99
Elgato HD60 X	1080p60 HDR10 or 4K30	4K60 HDR10, VRR	$179.99
AVerMedia Live Gamer Ultra 2.1	4K144 (Windows), 4K60 (macOS)	4K144 / 1440p240, HDR, VRR	$199.99 (sale)
Elgato 4K X	4K144	4K144 / 1440p240	$249.99

AVerMedia listed a regular price of $299.99 for the Live Gamer Ultra 2.1 beside the $199.99 sale price.

What your console and screen need

Match passthrough to how you play. A PlayStation 5 or Xbox Series X on a 4K 120Hz TV will be held to 60Hz at 4K by a card with 4K60 passthrough. If you play at 120Hz, look at the 4K X or the Live Gamer Ultra 2.1, which list HDMI 2.1 class passthrough at up to 4K144.

VRR, or variable refresh rate, keeps motion smooth when the frame rate moves. A card without VRR passthrough forces you to turn it off. The HD60 X and the Live Gamer Ultra 2.1 list VRR passthrough.

For streaming, 1080p60 capture is enough. Platforms limit bitrate, and few viewers receive more than 1080p. Capturing 4K matters when you record footage to edit into videos.

Connection, computer and audio

All five are external cards that connect by USB. Higher resolutions need a faster port. AVerMedia lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C at 10Gbps for the Live Gamer Ultra 2.1. Plugged into a slower port, a card may fall back to a lower mode or not work at all.

The computer does the encoding. Capturing 4K at high frame rates needs a recent graphics chip and a fast drive. AVerMedia lists 4K144 capture on Windows and 4K60 on macOS, so check your operating system.

Console party chat does not travel over HDMI on every console. AVerMedia lists 3.5mm jacks for a headset and a controller to bring chat audio into the capture. With other cards, a chat link cable or a workaround through the PC is the usual route.

How these picks were chosen

We chose external USB cards with published capture and passthrough figures, covering a 1080p entry model, a 4K60 model, two 4K144 models and an older VRR model. Four of the five come from Elgato, whose range covers most price steps, and one from AVerMedia. Internal PCIe cards are not covered.

Recommendations are editorial. No brand paid for placement, and the links on this page are affiliate links that may earn Pickly a commission at no extra cost to you.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to stream from a console?▼

Not always. PlayStation and Xbox can stream directly to some platforms. A capture card lets you add overlays, alerts, a camera and better audio through software on a computer.

Does a capture card add input lag?▼

Passthrough is designed to add no noticeable delay to the picture on your TV. The preview in the streaming software is delayed, so play on the passthrough screen.

Is 1080p60 capture enough?▼

For live streaming, yes. Choose 4K capture if you record footage to edit and upload at 4K.

Can I capture a Nintendo Switch?▼

Yes, in docked mode through HDMI. Any card here handles its output.

Will a capture card work with a Mac?▼

Check each maker's requirements. AVerMedia lists 4K60 as the maximum capture on macOS for the Live Gamer Ultra 2.1, lower than on Windows.

Why is the captured picture black?▼

The usual cause is HDCP copy protection. Turn off HDCP in the console's settings. Streaming apps on the console stay protected and cannot be captured.

Do I need a second PC?▼

No. One computer can capture a console. Two-PC setups are for PC gamers who want to move encoding off the gaming machine.